Back
The Debrief

When representation is not enough

Dan Cogan-Drew
Oct 13, 2020

Student engagement is always a challenge. And as has been reported, student engagement in remote learning is even more challenging. In order to properly diagnose and address student engagement, it’s necessary to understand some core principles in learning science that explain what motivates students to engage. Said another way: why will students choose to do school work in the face of other alternatives or obstacles, such as competing obligations (helping out around the house) or social invitations (gaming with friends)? 

There are many factors that contribute to a student’s motivation (read about them here) and the relationships amongst these can be complicated. In this post, I’m going to drill down on one in particular: belongingness. I’ll share a basic definition, reasons why a sense of belonging is so important to motivation, and how in the choice of representation, content providers often get it wrong and set teachers up to perpetuate alienation and even exclusion. 

We’ve written elsewhere about the importance of establishing and maintaining strong relationships with BIPOC students, especially in the time of distance learning. In this research note, we’re going to focus on auditing instructional content for its role in instilling a “sense of belonging” in learners. Here I want to emphasize that we need to go beyond representation - simply seeing oneself in the learning materials - to positive affirmation. It’s not simply about reviewing the scope and sequence to assess whether authors, protagonists, and historical figures represent a diversity of lived experience, but that the diversity be across multiple dimensions in order to portray individuals and groups in complex and not superficial ways. Black authors should not only be chosen for discussions of slavery, Japanese-American authors not only for studies of internment camps, Jewish authors not only for learning about the Holocaust. 

Too narrow and exclusive a focus exacerbates the hazards of a representation mindset evident in stereotype threat, which while enabling students to see themselves in the content, can serve also to reinforce negative perceptions of ability. These perceptions can in turn become a self-fulfilled reality.

Writing in the Hechinger Report, teacher Neven Holland captured the impact on his middle school students of positive, multi-dimensional portrayals of Black characters by actors like Chadwick Boseman as “fully human”:

To see Boseman and his castmates be fully human in “Black Panther” depicted a world that my students wanted to see — and did see. Boseman’s portrayal as King T’Challa gave them a sense of Black dignity. When my students see an overrepresentation of negative depictions of themselves in the media or little representation as the protagonist, those feelings of self-respect may waver.

When we choose content to publish on Newsela, we take great pains to ensure that the message sent by this content is not just one of representation - which can lead to stereotype threats if it simply reinforces negative media stereotypes - but one of positive affirmation of personal identity. As we state in our content guidelines: “We consider how a student will feel after reading an article, therefore no perspective presented on Newsela will make students feel attacked or marginalized.“ 

So what does this mean for instructional content and what can you as a designer or custodian of learning do about it?

Audit your instructional materials with an eye towards inclusivity for every student. Is this an image, a movie, a website, news article, primary source, or secondary source that presents individuals in a negative or stereotypical light? Does the language used in the instructional material make assumptions about the intended audience for whom it was written? Is there an implicit bias towards whiteness that further normalizes white skin and “others” bodies that are not representative of the majority? Are assumptions made about gender - in examples or anecdotes, stories that are foregrounded as characteristic of a period in history or the lived experience of a given population? Holland cites one example of research that very clearly documents the awareness even young children have of these biases and the impact it has on their own self-concept and sense of belonging.

Where students feel excluded because the choice of instructional content fails to account for their lived experience, their sense of belonging will falter, and so too will their motivation. Instead of starting at a place that assumes that students are motivated to engage with their instructional materials, let’s assume instead that unless we can explicitly identify what and exactly how the materials are sending them a strong signal that they belong in our class, that message is not getting through.

The Latest from @Newsela

Passionate, innovative, resourceful. These are just a few words to describe our community of Newsela Certified Educators. Our Newsela Certified Educator (NCE) program celebrates creativity and turns educators into leaders. https://t.co/xMFTgxyw1z
October 26, 2020, 3:32 PM
Although political parties have changed over time, the Democratic and Republican parties have been the primary parties since the 1850s. In this lesson, students will learn the history of the two party system and look at the political parties of today. https://t.co/mTQuldMcug https://t.co/eDMWq3SKUX
October 26, 2020, 2:25 PM
Ever wonder why trees throw away an important part of their anatomy each year? 🍁 After all, wouldn't it be similar to people losing all their hair - or even weirder, their skin - just as our part of the world gets colder? Let's explore: https://t.co/Om4kNfisYS https://t.co/4V2ldqnzDz
October 26, 2020, 12:33 AM
Political statements from artists in 2020 typically have been on the streets with murals and protest signs. However, the humble envelope is the object of this new art project. Get to know the artists using stamps as resistance: https://t.co/ifChvbA5aJ https://t.co/TuBlrNyJwR
October 25, 2020, 9:35 PM
We've added a brand new, interactive data analysis activity powered by Tuva Labs with polling data from 15,000+ students on how they're feeling about our nation's most pressing issues. https://t.co/4oBMeXjWjZ https://t.co/tjb3vzOGac
October 25, 2020, 8:04 PM
The Oakland African American Chamber of Commerce in Oakland, CA announced in summer 2020 that it had raised $1 million for its fund to help Black-owned businesses. Read how these "resiliency" grants are giving hope to the city's Black residents: https://t.co/YvteuVukL5 https://t.co/IsKLhwlqnU
October 25, 2020, 6:38 PM
Are you interested in hearing a district leader’s perspective on how their blended learning plan is working so far this school year? Then you'll definitely want to register for our upcoming webinar: https://t.co/3HFGzHd3RY https://t.co/jI2vppVgsG
October 25, 2020, 5:03 PM
Looks like a great Newsela training session! Keep learning, educators! 💙 https://t.co/9SK7wyUBsL
October 24, 2020, 9:55 PM
We’re giving our 25 million registered students a voice. Leading up to November, we’re releasing student polls to provide a future generation of voters with a platform to have their voices heard and votes counted. https://t.co/KaimJO4TRD https://t.co/uMUHANhPNQ
October 24, 2020, 8:04 PM
Human traffic to Taipei Zoo may have dropped in 2020 due to COVID-19, but zoo officials have been kept on their toes with an animal baby boom that has just kept coming. 🙉 Will all these new baby animals may draw more visitors? https://t.co/l5qxiMyesj https://t.co/8feyQcGtiT
October 24, 2020, 6:33 PM
Back in June @HeidiHayesJacob told us: “We can’t go back to school. We’re going to have to go forward to a new kind of school.” Now that the school year is underway, she joins us again to share smart strategies to adjust to blended or remote learning. https://t.co/3HFGzHd3RY https://t.co/z8gUbSchQc
October 24, 2020, 5:01 PM
The 2020 Nobel Prize in Chemistry has been awarded to Emmanuelle Charpentier and Jennifer Doudna for developing a process called "CRISPR-Cas9" which can snip a DNA molecule like a tiny pair of scissors. Curious why it's a game changer? Let's explore: https://t.co/TyOfmMzlKy https://t.co/tD3t5nkSYY
October 24, 2020, 3:35 PM
"Sesame Street" has always pressed for inclusion. Now in the wake of the national reckoning on race, it's going further. It is teaching children to stand up against racism. Here's how: https://t.co/KUvHSLSbU8 https://t.co/uvEOwsXWU1
October 24, 2020, 2:10 PM
This lesson helps students learn the importance of ancient seeds being reunited with their Native American tribes. "To us, seeds are our relatives," said Rowen White, an Indigenous seed keeper and leader of the Seed Savers Exchange board. https://t.co/CLspcZXDYC https://t.co/qMquOrm7eF
October 23, 2020, 10:45 PM
Pandemic-weary folks are flocking to pick-your-own apple and pumpkin farms. 🍎 🎃 Here are a few of the ways orchards are staying prepared for social distancing: https://t.co/MA6oyucKNK https://t.co/0Z1v4FElpZ
October 23, 2020, 6:35 PM

The best lessons start with the best content.

Ready to bring great instructional content to your students?

Contact Sales